Showing posts with label LONG TERM CARE COSTS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LONG TERM CARE COSTS. Show all posts

Sunday, August 1, 2010

ABUSING OUR KUPUNAS

EASIEST WAY TO ABUSE OUR KUPUNAS.... Just take away Medicare/Medicaid

What happens when the Government forces citizens into a medical reimbursement program and then decides to cut the reimbursements? My guess is that hospitals and doctors will begin to shut off access to care for Medicaid and Medicare patients. Hang on for a rough ride, folks.

Medicare is a medical insurance program that was promised to cover those who reached age 65. Part of the "Great Society" is what they called it. Medicaid is a welfare program where medical reimbursements are made for those who are on welfare and don't have insurance. Also part of the Great Society program under Social Security.

Beginning in August (at this writing), doctors will be forced to take a 21% cut in payments. The population specifically affected include seniors, the disabled and military patients on the Tricare program. Folks like me who made sure we served 20 years in order to qualify for medical benefits as military retirees believe that we kept up our part of the bargain by serving in the military. At great risk of life and limb, by the way. The government has decided to modify its promises by cutting payments. And they will have to do the same with Social Security, the recently passed universal health care and all other government programs because they no longer have any money.


Here I am at the Blaisdell Concert Hall, risking life and limb for my country

What will the elderly do? Many medical facilities will still take them in if they can pay cash. Others will not receive services if the person is on Medicare. In many places (costs vary with locations), Medicare only reimburses 50% of the actual cost of primary care. Cutting another 21% likely will further leave our elderly without care because providers will turn them away.

http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/content/view/30562/

Congress is as confused as ever, but, they need to find ways to pay for the 48 million uninsured people that were promised coverage under the Health Care Reform passed earlier this year. So, they chose to cut Medicare.

http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/Stories/2010/June/25/week-in-review.aspx


Sort of like government bureaucrats deciding who will get care and who won't. Or, perhaps lawyers will be making such decisions. Or, an accountant. If a person is older and highly likely to pass away, then certain medications may be withheld. Or surgical procedures. Or treatment and rehabilitation services. The decisions used to be made by the practitioner and the patient. Not so anymore.

http://www.heartland.org/healthpolicy-news.org/article/27913/Mayo_Clinic_Makes_Medicare_Medicaid_Cuts.html


We need to become less dependent on our government and become involved with our respective communities. Churches previously served their communities by providing relief for neighbors whether it's a health issue or a financial issue, or, as in this case, both. Not so anymore. If you belong to a church, strongly urge the leaders in your church to create more community outreach programs. If you don't belong to a church, then  find some way in which you can help those who cannot help themselves.

If someone in our community needs help, we can help to raise money and/or voluntarily give up resources to assist those in need. Sort of like a barn raising, if you will. And as a side benefit, we may again have communities where neighbors get to know and work with each other.

We can do it. Like filling up a bucket one drop at a time. And leave our government out of it. They have no money of their own. They merely take from Peter to pay Paul, which makes Peter feel abused. When Peter is abused he doesn't work. Uh, oh! Doesn't sound very family-friendly. But you know what I mean.

Sunday, June 6, 2010

DON THE PINHEAD III

DON THE PINHEAD III


O.K., O.K. Deep down, I'm a pinhead.

A pinhead is someone who basically doesn't do anything, but assigns blame, does a lot of studies and, puts a boot on some one's throat or neck. Somewhat like our government.



When it comes to caring for our kupunas, the ones who do the actual work, like changing diapers, giving medical care, cleaning them up, and doing all the things that our kupunas can no longer do for themselves are the primary targets of the pinheads.

The following article appeared in the newspapers the other day.

http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20100525/NEWS01/5250334/Hawaii+home-care+horror+tales+underscore+risk+to+elderly


This article presents a strong case for creating more laws, regulations and control over our paid caregivers. To be clear, I do not support our paid caregivers who abuse our kupunas. I do object, however, to having our government increase the regulations on the very people who we depend on to provide this vital service to our aging population. Increased government regulations will increase the costs for everyone and people who cannot afford full service care will not have options for lower levels of service.

Further, more regulations results in more pinheads who are paid more money to tell the caregivers what to do. It doesn't make sense to have more pinheads than caregivers.

See my Pinhead I article.

http://malamakupuna.blogspot.com/2010/04/don-pinhead.html

Something that may be of a bigger concern is when a person chooses to be a caregiver and the kupuna dies while under that person's care and is charged and convicted of criminal negligence.

http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20100520/NEWS20/5200321/Woman+sentenced+to+30+days+for+mother+s+death


There are a few facts to remember. First, is that sometimes the kupunas die even under the best of care. They develop bedsores and flesh-eating bacteria in hospitals all the time. Second, is that the average person wouldn't know how to care for the aged because most have not acquired the skills, much less the medical knowledge required. A Certified Nurses' Aide is not a trained medical professional. Most courses for that certification run about 3 months. All these caregivers can do is to do their best.

If the government goes after those who provide care for their loved ones because they either cannot afford nursing or care homes, then many people will opt out of being caregivers. For most people, that's an easy choice because they normally suffer financially, physically and emotionally when they become caregivers. See my Pinhead II article.

http://malamakupuna.blogspot.com/2010/04/don-pinhead-part-ii.html

So what's the solution? First, is that everyone has to watch for our elderly. That's what healthy communities do. Not pass the responsibility to the government. In the cases of paid caregivers defrauding or abusing their patients, it often happens because family members are not paying attention. They don't visit their loved ones and instead, expect the paid caregiver to take care of everything. Even the best of facilities make mistakes and if family members visit regularly, they can keep a watchful eye or even help when staff members are overloaded.

The second solution, and one which won't require government intervention is to require or demand full disclosure by the paid caregiver. This requires individual responsibility to know exactly which services are provided and which are not. Many choose low-level care because that's all they can afford.  If that's the case, you should  keep a watchful eye on the caregiver, perhaps by helping out when you can. The choice to keep your loved ones there is yours.

Many kupunas don't have family members that can watch out for them. That's where community involvement comes into play. Churches, volunteer groups and other benevolent organizations can help to keep a watchful eye for our kupunas. Heck, I know of at least one State employee who, while working for Social Services, stole from and was convicted of defrauding an elderly client of thousands of dollars. That person now sells annuities and long-term-care insurance to the elderly.

Things become complicated because many care homes have patients receiving Medicaid, which is a taxpayer-funded program. When taxpayers pay, then the government has a duty to regulate and oversee the care. The caregiver cannot, for instance, charge the Medicaid patient $200 a day and charge the patients who struggle to pay out of their own pockets $100 a day. That is committing fraud against the government because it's overcharging the government for the same service. But, it also ends up pricing many non-Medicaid people out of the market.

We have many retired professionals who can offer volunteer guidance on how to spot situations where the kupuna is being defrauded. Retirees are valuable resources that need to be tapped. Or, we can have a nanny state. Except that most states are already bankrupt and can't meet fiscal and pension obligations to existing employees. So we end up with unfunded regulations that cannot be enforced. And we pinheads will continue to multiply.

Saturday, April 17, 2010

DON THE PINHEAD PART II

DON THE PINHEAD PART II


Some of you couldn't pass the entrance test for Farrington High School so had to go to Punahou or Iolani. I can tell from the comments you've made.

Mostly, many are concerned about costs to care for the elderly. Some financial planners, social workers, lawyers and other professionals regularly urge clients to transfer their wealth to their children so that they can then qualify for Medicaid. Medicaid is welfare. This is fraudulent practice. And if someone recommends these types of actions, you should turn them in to the authorities and have them prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

Sparky, an 85 year old, visits his wife daily at the nursing home. He's unable to care for her at home but is able to spend time with her every day and makes sure that her needs are met. He also helps with other patients.

There is a difference, however, if someone transfers assets or control over assets to family members or to a charity to lower estate tax obligations. That is a legitimate planning move. The estate owner still has sizable amounts left to pay for his/her own long-term care so is not making such transfers in order to fraudulently qualify for welfare.

When a person transfers all of his assets to the children, other problems surface besides the fraud issue. The first, is that the person making the transfer loses his/her dignity because he/she becomes an instant pauper. They say that the difference between an elderly gent and an old man is money. That's because the elderly suddenly becomes a dependent and loses his position of respect and leverage in the family and societal structure. I'm aware of parents who are forced to live in, and take their meals in a single small room and not be allowed to eat with the rest of the family after giving their house to their children. Parental abuse like this is rarely reported because parents don't like to sue their children. And, children are often seen as being saints for "allowing the parents to live with them".

Then, problems between siblings often arise when one sibling has to take on the responsibility of caring for the elderly parents. That sibling/caregiver quits working and often has to pay for the elderly's medical needs and drugs out of his/her pocket. Suppose a person makes $50,000 a year. Becoming a fulltime caregiver means that the person loses that income. Further, drugs and out-of-pocket medical needs may cost another $12,000 or more a year. That caregiver should be entitled to take some of the assets and income the parent has, to compensate for the losses.

That's when greed surfaces. Siblings may not understand that the previously well-to-do caregiver/sibling is losing money and assets. Or don't care to understand that, because they have their eye on the potential inheritance from their parents. Or, siblings may have spouses who resent that their future "inheritance" is being spent by the caregiver. Sometimes lawsuits are filed. And, if it doesn't get to that stage, lawsuits are filed after the death of the elderly parent(s) causing financial and emotional grief that continue for years after the passing.

It is common for the caregiver to have to hire someone to cover for respite periods to allow the caregiver time to rest and take care of other chores required for daily living. If one hires a person for $10 an hour, 10 hours a day for 7 days a week, that comes up to $36,400 a year. The caregiver is now an employer and must also pay for workers comp insurance, unemployment insurance, Temporary Disability insurance, Social Security Taxes, Medicare taxes, provide medical insurance, etc. on top of the $36,400. Failure to do so exposes the caregiver to prosecution for tax fraud and breaking employment laws. Further, the "employee" may sue the caregiver for unemployment, worker comp claims, etc. after legal counsel advises of these entitlement possibilities. We can assume the actual cost to hire respite help to be about $65,000 annually if done legally and properly.

The caregiver is also exposed to lawsuits by siblings or other family members because accidents happen and often, the elderly falls regardless of how careful the caregiver is. The caregiver must spend money defending against such lawsuits and if proven to be negligent, must pay the judgment as well as the legal fees. Homeowners insurance generally won't cover such lawsuits, especially if it can be proven that some money is paid to the caregiver even if the money is used for the benefit of the elderly parent. The money exchange may constitute a business transaction.

Sometimes the elderly parent may not wish to release money to the caregiver because parents want to treat each child fairly and if money is given to one, then, in all "fairness", the same amount must be given to all the children. Sometimes, they even want to keep their assets intact so it can be a legacy for themselves and want all assets to be given to the grandchildren so they would be remembered fondly. The elderly often loses perspective and logic.

The solution is for thorough and complete communication among all interested family members and regular meetings should be conducted with each party receiving complete minutes of such meetings and that all financial matters be disclosed.

Some will still sue, but at least the documentation is there for the caregiver's defense. And, in most cases, there is a lifetime resentment that develops among the siblings because everyone can only see things from his/her perspective. The caregiver usually loses. As does the kupuna who has to witness the family greed.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

DON THE PINHEAD

O.K. I'll be a pinhead. But only this once... or twice.


I've received a bunch of emails on the series that the Advertiser ran on the elderly. Seems like readers believe that I'm advocating for more regulations by the state because I've posted the link on my personal profile. That is far from the truth. So I'll explain.

Don Having fun with patient in nursing home

I'm a proud Graduate of Farrington High School so I know lots of things. I was on full scholarship because I don't recall paying any tuition. Whatever I don't know, I readily make up. So I'll give you the real scoop.

The more government involvement, the more long-term-care costs will be. And the fewer choices will be available to those in need of the services.

Here's the Advertiser series:

http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/section/kupuna_day1/(No+heading)

Currently, charges run from $50 a day for adult day care (must be ambulatory) to $300 a day or more for acute nursing care. In between are facilities with charges based upon the amount of care the patient requires.

Let's examine some of the factors that go into the cost of running a care facility. A certified nurse's aide (CNA) gets paid about $10 an hour. We'll use this figure because I'm not very bright and it'll be easier for me to do the calculations.

The facility needs to generate revenue equal to twice that amount in order to break even. That's because they have to pay for worker compensation insurance, Temporary Disability insurance (TDI), Unemployment insurance, medical insurance, Social Security and Medicare premiums. There is also the cost of professional liability insurance in addition to the comprehensive general liability insurance premiums on the operation and premises.

The facility also must pay for support services, including supervisory costs, rent or facilities costs, etc. If the State increases the regulatory requirements, then those reporting and administrative costs must also be added to the cost of operations. Labor to fill and maintain file cabinets costs money.

Generally, regulatory costs are included in the licensing fees by the state and that is charged to care operators. I'm not sure it includes the costs to operate both the licensing board and the Regulated Industries Complaints Office (RICO). But increased rules and regulations also increases the State's cost to inspect, examine complaints and to issue judgments.

Once a report goes to a state agency, the state has culpability and must examine every report in detail. Many want more regulation because the State is considered to have "deep pockets". So if a State employee is paid $15 an hour to examine paperwork, they need to increase tax/fees revenues by 250% of that amount because of the generous employee benefits programs that the state offers. The amounts paid out to settle lawsuits are charged to taxpayers.

And these additional costs are passed on to the consumer by the facility or the facility goes belly up.

Here's a solution if anyone cares.

Require each facility to completely disclose everything to each entering resident/patient. If they do not carry professional liability insurance, or if they have very low limits, then that should be a part of the disclosure and written agreement. You can even be named as "additional insured" on the liability policy so if the policy lapses, you would be notified.

A clearing house could also be set up to register the number of complaints (not anonymously) each facility receives. This could be set up by the professional association and be available online. The data gives a prospective patient relevant facts to make an informed decision.

The result is that each person (or appropriate family members) entering a facility, having received such complete disclosure takes responsibility for the choice made. If they decide to choose a low-cost facility by selecting a facility that shaves costs, then they are entering into the agreement with their eyes wide open. This gives people a wide range of choices on the already shrinking supply of care facilities.

Lawsuits are also remedies open to patients and families of patients. If the care home operator doesn't carry professional liability insurance, you may want to ask them to provide you with a financial statement prepared by a CPA to determine if assets are available should a lawsuit is necessary. Or not. Your choice. Everyone has choices and is responsible for his decisions.

If the Advertiser article still bothers you because you believe that it advocates for more regulations instead of being fair journalism, then you may want to stop buying the newspaper.

Freedom with individual responsibility is wonderful.